Skip to main content
VPNchek

Updated April 2026

Best Private Internet Access Alternatives (2026)

We ranked the top 5 Private Internet Access alternatives by score, privacy, streaming, and price. Rankings are based on test data.

Why people leave Private Internet Access

Price

Many users switch VPNs to find better value. Compare pricing and features below to find the right fit for your budget.

Speed or reliability

Speed varies by server location, network conditions, and VPN protocol. Testing alternatives on your specific route often reveals better options.

Feature set

Not all VPNs support port forwarding, multi-hop, split tunneling, or Tor integration. If you need a specific feature, filter alternatives below.

Top Private Internet Access alternatives

1
NordVPN

The proven choice for most people.

Best Overall
9.2/10
Excellent

NordVPN has the largest verified server network, consistently fast speeds, and a independently audited no-logs policy. It costs more than Surfshark but the reliability gap is measurable — especially on streaming.

96%

Speed kept

111

Countries

$3.39

/mo 2-yr plan

  • 6,400+ servers in 111 countries — the widest real network we've tested
  • Independent no-logs audit by Deloitte (2024)
  • Meshnet feature lets you connect your own devices without extra cost
  • More expensive than Surfshark or Private Internet Access
See NordVPN dealFull review →

30-day money-back guarantee

Full review →Private Internet Access vs NordVPN →Get deal →
2
ProtonVPN

Built by the team behind ProtonMail. Privacy is the product.

Best for Privacy
9.1/10
Excellent

ProtonVPN is the strongest privacy-first choice if you distrust VPN marketing claims. The no-logs policy has been court-tested, the apps are fully open source, and the Swiss jurisdiction is the most legally favorable for privacy in Europe.

87%

Speed kept

91

Countries

$3.99

/mo 2-yr plan

  • Strongest verifiable privacy: open-source apps, court-tested no-logs policy
  • Swiss jurisdiction — outside EU and US data retention laws
  • Secure Core routes traffic through hardened servers in Iceland, Sweden, Switzerland
  • Speeds slower than NordVPN or ExpressVPN — 87% retention
See ProtonVPN dealFull review →

30-day money-back guarantee

Full review →Private Internet Access vs ProtonVPN →Get deal →
3
Surfshark

Unlimited devices. Honest price. No surprises.

Best Value
9.0/10
Excellent

Surfshark covers unlimited devices for under $2.50/month on the 2-year plan. Speed is slightly behind NordVPN but more than sufficient. The unlimited simultaneous connections policy alone makes it the obvious choice for households or anyone with more than 5 devices.

91%

Speed kept

100

Countries

$2.19

/mo 2-yr plan

  • Unlimited simultaneous connections — covers every device in your household
  • Under $2.50/month on 2-year plan — the best price-to-feature ratio we've found
  • CleanWeb blocks ads, malware, and trackers (works across all apps, not just browser)
  • Slightly lower speed retention than NordVPN — 91% vs 96%
See Surfshark dealFull review →

30-day money-back guarantee

Full review →Private Internet Access vs Surfshark →Get deal →
4
Mullvad

No email. No account name. Flat €5/month. That's it.

Best for Anonymity
8.7/10
Very Good

Mullvad is the only mainstream VPN with genuinely anonymous accounts — you get a random number, not an email address. Flat €5/month with no multi-year lock-in. If maximum privacy is the requirement, this is the answer.

89%

Speed kept

46

Countries

€5.50

/mo annual

  • Anonymous account creation — number only, no email, no name, no tracking
  • Accepts cash payments for complete financial anonymity
  • Flat €5/month — no confusing discount tiers or introductory pricing traps
  • No streaming optimization — unreliable on Netflix, Disney+, BBC iPlayer
See Mullvad dealFull review →
Full review →Private Internet Access vs Mullvad →Get deal →
5
ExpressVPN

The fastest VPN we've ever tested. At a price.

Fastest Speeds
8.6/10
Very Good

ExpressVPN is the fastest VPN we've tested and the easiest to use — but at $8.32/month it's nearly twice the price of NordVPN. Justified only if raw speed or near-zero setup friction is your primary requirement.

98%

Speed kept

105

Countries

$8.32

/mo annual

  • Fastest speeds we've recorded — 98% speed retention on nearby servers
  • Lightway protocol (proprietary, open-source) is genuinely fast and audited
  • Consistently unblocks all major streaming platforms
  • $8.32/month is the most expensive mainstream VPN — hard to justify vs. NordVPN
See ExpressVPN dealFull review →

30-day money-back guarantee

Full review →Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN →Get deal →

Frequently asked questions

Is Private Internet Access worth it in 2026?

Private Internet Access scores 8.4/10 in our testing — solid but with notable trade-offs. PIA runs the world's largest verified server network at ~$2/month. The no-logs policy has been confirmed in two separate US court cases. It's not the fastest, but for price-conscious users who need proven privacy, it's hard to beat.

What's cheaper than Private Internet Access?

Private Internet Access starts at $2.03/month on its best plan. Among the alternatives above, Surfshark and PIA offer lower pricing while maintaining strong feature coverage.

What's more private than Private Internet Access?

For maximum privacy, Mullvad and IVPN offer anonymous account creation (no email required), accept cash payments, and have been independently audited with zero logged data. ProtonVPN is headquartered in Switzerland with open-source apps and court-verified no-logs. If privacy is the primary concern, any of these three are stronger choices than most mainstream VPNs.